Before censorship or scandal codes existed, cinema’s earliest flirtations with homosexuality were surprisingly open—if short-lived. The 1919 German film Anders als die Andern (Different from the Others) told of two men in love and condemned the anti-gay laws of the time. Written by sexologist Magnus Hirschfeld, it was daring, human, and sympathetic—until the Nazis destroyed nearly all prints.
By Allan R. Ellenberger for The Hollywoodland Revue
The Silent Shadows (1910s–1920s)
In America, any same-sex subtext was quickly filtered through humor or disguise—men dancing together in early Edison shorts or women masquerading as men in A Florida Enchantment (1914).
Then came William Haines, MGM’s top box-office star in the late 1920s. Openly gay among friends, he refused Louis B. Mayer’s demand to marry a woman for publicity. MGM fired him—but Haines reinvented himself as a top Hollywood interior designer, living out a fifty-year romance with his partner Jimmy Shields. His was one of the few happy endings in an era that demanded tragedy.
Another early pioneer was James Whale, the English director of Frankenstein (1931) and Bride of Frankenstein (1935). His films brimmed with coded camp, sympathy for outsiders, and Gothic elegance—expressions of his own identity. Later marginalized by the studio system and suffering ill health, Whale took his own life in 1957. His story, dramatized in Gods and Monsters, remains one of Hollywood’s great cautionary tales.
The Closet Years (1930s–1940s)
The introduction of the Hays Code in 1934 banned “sex perversion” outright. From then on, homosexuality was either invisible or villainous. Yet queer artists found ways to survive—and even to subvert.
Marlene Dietrich in tuxedo kissed a woman in Morocco (1930). Greta Garbo’s androgynous allure in Queen Christina (1933) echoed rumors of her relationships with women. And in Rebecca (1940), Judith Anderson’s icy Mrs. Danvers practically worshiped her dead mistress.
Off-screen, George Cukor, director of The Philadelphia Story and My Fair Lady, became the discreet patriarch of Hollywood’s gay creative elite. His Beverly Hills home was the site of Saturday salons that mixed actors, writers, and designers who could not be themselves elsewhere. Cukor’s secret was simple: elegance, silence, and success.
Forbidden Desire and Tragic Icons (1950s–1960s)
As postwar America demanded conformity, the closet deepened. Films such as Tea and Sympathy (1956) and The Children’s Hour (1961) explored queer subtext, but only as moral warning.
The British film Victim (1961) broke that pattern—it was the first to use the word “homosexual” openly. Its star, Dirk Bogarde, himself gay, risked his career for honesty.
Then came Rock Hudson—handsome, charming, and utterly trapped. Universal Pictures crafted his heterosexual image with ruthless precision. Behind the scenes, he lived cautiously among friends and lovers until AIDS forced his truth into the open. When he died in 1985, his name humanized the disease for millions. His tragedy marked both an ending and a beginning.
Others suffered quieter fates: Tab Hunter’s career derailed after being outed; Sal Mineo was murdered in 1976, his sexuality whispered but rarely defended. Their pain mirrored a world still unready for authenticity.
Out of the Shadows (1970s–1980s)
The sexual revolution, then the AIDS epidemic, defined these decades. Theatrical and film work grew bolder—The Boys in the Band (1970) depicted gay men with frankness and self-critique; Dog Day Afternoon (1975) placed a transgender relationship at its emotional core; Making Love (1982) gave mainstream audiences their first tender same-sex love story.
The AIDS years brought profound loss—and extraordinary art. Parting Glances (1986) and Longtime Companion (1990) offered courage and compassion when little else did.
Historians like Vito Russo, author of The Celluloid Closet, documented decades of cinematic erasure. His work—and his activism with ACT UP—preserved memory amid mourning.
New Queer Cinema (1990s)
Out of the ashes rose defiance. Independent filmmakers rejected pity and moralism, crafting bold, sensual, and angry stories.
Directors like Gus Van Sant (My Own Private Idaho), Gregg Araki (The Living End), and Rose Troche (Go Fish) celebrated queer life with unapologetic style. Spanish auteur Pedro Almodóvar dazzled with color, desire, and complexity in Law of Desire and All About My Mother.
Actors like Ian McKellen came out publicly and kept working, defying the old rule that honesty meant career suicide. A “New Queer Cinema” was born—restless, ironic, self-aware, and gloriously free.
Visibility and Validation (2000s–2010s)
Hollywood finally began telling stories of love, not pathology.
Brokeback Mountain (2005) broke the dam—a sweeping romance between two men, handled with dignity and longing. Milk (2008) honored slain activist Harvey Milk. Carol (2015) turned 1950s repression into exquisite art. And Moonlight (2016) became the first LGBTQ-themed film to win the Oscar for Best Picture.
Meanwhile, openly gay and lesbian artists flourished: Ellen DeGeneres, Sir Elton John, Neil Patrick Harris, Tilda Swinton, Laverne Cox, and Ryan Murphy each changed the image of success itself.
Integration and Global Voices (2020s–Today)
Queer stories now cross genres and continents: Marvel superheroes, Disney animation, historical dramas, and global streaming platforms all feature LGBTQ+ characters with unprecedented openness.
Films like The Power of the Dog (2021), Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022), Red, White & Royal Blue (2023), and series like Heartstopper celebrate nuance instead of novelty.
Openly gay and trans filmmakers—Lana and Lilly Wachowski, Todd Haynes, Andrew Haigh, Cheryl Dunye, and many others—work without disguises, reclaiming the right denied their predecessors.
Epilogue: From Silence to Symphony
For over a century, Hollywood’s relationship with homosexuality has moved from subtext to spotlight, from shame to celebration. Behind the screen are the real stories—of men like James Whale, who couldn’t survive; of William Haines, who quietly thrived; of Rock Hudson, whose death changed hearts; and of today’s filmmakers, who live openly in the light their predecessors never knew.
The reel keeps turning, and the rainbow—once hidden in black and white—now spans the full spectrum of cinema.
Share your thoughts below — I’d love to hear your take on this piece and Gay Hollywood’s ever-unfolding story.
Add comment
Comments